Our Series on Innovative Therapies
Cranial Electrotherapy Stimulation (CES)
What is the
history of CES?
A. At least two millennium ago, physicians used electric eels to relieve pain. Experimentation with
low intensity electrical stimulation of the brain was first reported by Drs. Leduc and Rouxeau of France in 1902. Research
on using what is now referred to as cranial electrotherapy stimulation (CES) for treatment of anxiety began in the Soviet
Union during the 1950's, its primary focus being the treatment of sleep disorders, hence its initial designation as "electrosleep."
Treatment of insomnia was soon overshadowed, however, by psychiatric application for depression and anxiety. Since then, it
has been referred to by many other names, the most popular being transcranial electrotherapy (TCET) and neuroelectric therapy
(NET).
East European nations soon picked up CES as a treatment modality and its use spread worldwide. by the late 1960's,
animal studies of CES had begun in the United States at the University of Tennessee and what is now the University of Wisconsin
Medical school.
These were soon followed by human clinical trials at the University of Texas Medical school in San
Antonio and the University of Wisconsin Medical School. More studies have followed. At present, the number of human studies
stands at 103. In addition, there are 18 experimental animal studies, all of which attest to the safety of CES.
Description: Class IIa. Type BF medical device
generating microcurrent pulses that are thought to reach the brain directly via ear lobe stimulation with 42% reaching the
cortex through a perineural or vascular pathway via the auditory meatus. Frequency: 0.5 to 60hz. Output:
4.0 mA maximum. Waveform: Bipolar asymmetric rectangular waves, 500/a duty cycle. 0 net current. Average current density in
brain tissue: 1 mA: 5-18 uA per cm. Electric field in brain tissue at 1 mA: 2.8 to 8 mV per cm.
Method of Action: Cranial electrostimulation
uses microcurrent pulsed high frequency carrier waves (15,000 Hz) which utilizes the bulk capacitance of the body and a modulating
bioactive frequency at low current levels to reestablish optimal neurotransmitter levels and functioning in the brain. CES
differs from traditional transcutaneous electrical nerve stimulation (TENS) which is low-frequency (200 Hz or less), high-current
(hundreds of mA) modality. Low-level electrical current interacts with cell membranes in a manner that produces modifications
in information transduction associated with classical second messenger pathways, calcium channels and cyclic AMP. The activity/levels
of MAO-B in blood platelets, CSF and plasma serotonin beta endorphin GABA concentration in blood. DHEA, 5-hydroxy-indol-acetic
acid and enkephalins were all increased in experimental groups after 20 CES procedures. Cortisol and trvptophane levels decreased.
Electrical engineering studies found that a small fraction of CES current actually reaches the thalamic area of the brain
facilitating the release of neurotransmitters as noted above. A decrease in the latency of alpha-rhythm appearance at sleep
onset has also been recorded with CES use evidencing reduced rigidity in the CNS stimulation process and enhanced activity
of the alpha-rhythm generating systems.
Indications and Usage: In carefully conducted
randomized controlled trials CES has repeatedly shown efficacy in treating mild to moderate primary or secondary anxiety and
depressive conditions, normalization of central hemodynamics (systolic and diastolic blood pressure but not peripheral vascular
tension) in Stage I hypertension, relieving headache pain (85%) and other types of pain conditions including pain resulting
from dental surgery and cancer (35%), and especially in potentiating through centrally-mediated action the effect of analgesic
drugs (fentanyl 176%-306%, morphine 174%-306%, alfentanil I 60%-2 15% and dextromoramide 267%-392%), or replacing them altogether
and increasing the depth of anesthesia (In one study fentanyl use decreased by 31%.). and increasing attention and the ability
to learn new tasks. To a lesser degree CES has been shown effective in relieving primary insomnia (particularly sleep-onset
insomnia), mild depression, post-axonic spasticity, minimal brain dysfunction and mood changes subsequent to closed head injury
(with corresponding decrease in the need to neuroleptic drugs). Efficacy of CES has been researched in regards to substance
abuse recovery (including nicotine and opiate addiction) with mixed results.
Contraindications: Do not use this product
if you are pregnant or lactating without first seeking advice from your physician. Do no use if you have a cardiac pacemaker
(particularly demand type pacemakers) or other implanted bioelectric equipment without first consulting your physician. There
have been isolated reports of CES treatment lowering blood pressure so care should be taken while using CES in conjunction
with high blood pressure medication

CES
engages the serotonergic (5-HT) raphe nuclei of the brainstem. 5-HT inhibits brainstem cholinergic (ACh) and noradrenergic
(NE) systems that project supratentorially. This suppresses thalamo-cortical activity, arousal, agitation, alters sensory
processing and induces EEG alpha rhythm. As well, 5-HT can act directly to modulate pain sensation in the dorsal horn of the
spinal cord, and alter pain perception, cognition and emotionality within the limbic forebrain.
Legend:
Blue arrows: inhibitory interactions
Purple arrows: excitatory interactions
X : suppressed pathways/interactions
Abbreviations:
ACh: actetylcholine
LDT: laterodorsal tegmental nucleus of the brainstem
PPN: pediculo-ponitne nucleus of the brainstem
NE: norepinephrine
LC: locus ceruleus
5-HT: serotonin
Note: Diagram not to scale
James Giordano, Ph.D.
|
|